Album Review: Oh Captain, My Captain

Lorri Ehin Oct 08 2008 12:37P 3

Oh Captain My Captain - Recklessly She Split The Sea Releases November 10th, 2008
Annie Marie, the second track, first song on Oh Captain My Captain's, "Recklessly She Split The Sea", interrupts a cheesy intro, that couldn't be any worse if they had called it "Opening Credits"; oh wait, they did. Annie Marie is a sad pathetic song about a wimp. It describes a girl that cheats on a boy and of course he's devastated. He's so angry he says things like: "Baby take your time getting home tonight, cause you'll be alone." He really lays into her when at the end of the song he tells her: I don't want to be seen with you in public, there's nothing I can do with you. " Uh, she's in public with someone else, you probably should have written the song a couple months sooner.

Too bad…
These guys play like motherfuckers. The guitars, bass, drums, and vocals pummel you with perfection, not only in performance, which is remarkable, but, the production, which is exact and honest. The collaboration of piano and strings in addition to the band as a whole never sound forced or cluttered. They groove like no tomorrow. Yet, imagine Weezer without the irony, pretty bad right? Well there you go.

There are moments of beauty. Just about two minutes into "All My Good Luck" , the energy of the first six songs crumbles. Before this, it had built violently towards hope. At this moment it gives in. It hurts. You know exactly how it feels. Especially when the band slams everything around and turns hurt into adrenalin. The cruelty of both sides in a a relationship comes out in this song, especially if you've heard the connection song on this album. A song I hate, ("Annie Marie") becomes better, thanks to another song halfway through the thing.
They quickly ruin it with the next track.

"Don't Be A Hero" is a nighmare of excess that only gets worse by the second. Perhaps I don't understand, but shit goes to full suck, right about there, and never recovers.

Recorded at Cystal Lake Studios and with members of members of members of mebers of bands with mebers of people who are in bands with them.This album reeks of nepotism and incest. We should all be ashamed. It's our fault.

Songs to download: On My Mind [.mp3], "Annie Marie" , "All My Good Luck"

-Lorrie Ehin

Check out all of Oh Captain, My Captain's shows on pc-pdx.

talk about it …


  1. Chauncey Miloker

    Oh brother....

  2. pc-pdx

    --Big thanks to Lorri for posting the review. It's a bit biting at points, but one listeners honest interpretation of the album and that's kind of refreshing. We want to encourage people to contribute and bring discussion around all this, please leave your comments on this and other articles. PC-PDX is all about building up the local scene and promoting fantastic bands so if you have opinions on this article, post it!

    I, quite surprisingly, had a little different take on the album:

    Lorri says "Don't Be A Hero" is a nightmare of excess that only gets worse by the second. I think it's a comforting classic that brings together alot of what i like about this band.

    Don't be a hero is wintertime carousel of tiptoeing guitars and what i imagine that Narnias version of Radiohead "The Bends" would sound like.
    "Bright as I've Ever Been" is like Amile meets mid 90's male crap rock. Much of the album is the same, it offers the mystical and dreamy atmospherics like the film Amile can make you feel. It also pulls memories of 90's mediocrity from bands like Dogs Eye view and Deep Blue Something.

    This record really wins with towering sound, solid guitars and overall tight as can be rhythm. The frontman isn't exactly my favorite, he offers up some clever lines but overall not really my style of frontman. That being said, he strikes me as being PDX's indie scene's syle of frontman and will be greatly appreciated on this album, just as OCMC always has.

    With a few exceptions, this is a pretty decent album and hasn't left my shuffle in the last two weeks. I digg the 70's rock-and-roll feel you can pull out of this album and it's still Portland enough to remember there's still time to see these guys in your neighbors basement.

  3. I'm excessively excited for a new album!
    I didn't even know!

Max 4000 chars What say you?
useless facts

263 upcoming shows @ 49 different spots

51 upcoming shows with flyers

51 ALL AGES shows!

Find shows, photos, blogs
Jake Prog and experimental rock this Saturday at Old Gilbert Road Tavern! Rainbow Face and Mingus Uh-Oh
-9/11/2019 8:32:22 AM
Electric Ring @fixin' to, the [Sep 19, 2019] » A//TAR record release? Oh hell yes!
-9/5/2019 3:23:18 PM
Da Punx Sinbad take over PORTLAND! HE LEGIT! 1990s Bay bee!!! HOLLA!!!! Dad-core 4ever!!
-8/28/2019 12:26:55 AM
phil @lay low tavern [Aug 27, 2019] » hdhdh
-8/27/2019 4:47:06 PM
show-bot! all the shows have an edit history if you wanna check who did what and when
-8/1/2019 8:47:29 AM
Im so dumb Why'd you remove the Old City and Autocracy show on 8/2 and replace it with a show ar Misdemeanor Meadows? These shows aren'tv related at all. No love, 503 punx.
-8/1/2019 8:43:41 AM
John @post 134 [Aug 08, 2019] » 8pm start time? How old do you think I am, 21?
-7/31/2019 10:46:50 AM
AJ @billy blues bar and grill [Jul 28, 2019] » The Glenn Cannon debut CD "Devil in the Sunshine" dropped July 12th! ¤ It’s a KILLER Rock Record. ¤ You can hear it at one of the links below. ¤ ¤ Spotify:… ¤ ¤ YouTube:… ¤ ¤
-7/20/2019 8:07:25 PM
Curt @waypost, the [Jul 12, 2019] » BULL MARKET ¤ ¤ ¤ TOIM ¤ ¤ ¤ HEAVY MEDICAL ¤
-7/8/2019 8:01:49 AM
does blast house still do shows?
-7/1/2019 9:41:41 AM
NASALROD + DIRTY PRINCESS - FREE at RONTOMS - SUNDAY JULY 7TH! @rontoms [Jul 07, 2019] » Stoked for this & Banana Stand Media will be filming the event!!! FB event page:
-6/29/2019 5:53:30 PM
people need to be aware that jon scheid from u sco and duck little brother duck is a sexual predator
-6/28/2019 8:57:03 PM
AKM @tonic lounge [Jun 29, 2019] » Sad to see the Tonic go. Glad to play this stage one more time before it does. Thank you for making Portland one of the best cities for music in the US.
-6/28/2019 4:10:41 PM
Electric Ring @tonic lounge [Aug 02, 2019] » Damn that flyer is lit!
-6/24/2019 12:43:42 PM
@rontoms [Jun 23, 2019] » Not to be missed! Great lineup and going to be one bitchin' patio show!
-6/18/2019 3:43:39 PM
Punx @ask a punk [Jun 01, 2019] » Venue is on the sw side of the ross island bridge , the Secret Palace !
-5/30/2019 9:38:30 PM
Ellisa Sun @marino's coffee shop [May 31, 2019] » SO STOKED FOR THIS LAST MINUTE SHOW! HOPE TO SEE YA THERE PORTLAND!
-5/28/2019 11:53:58 PM
La Inquisición = fascists La Inquisición = fascists and apolitics
-5/22/2019 5:05:18 PM
swank @east side bar and grill [May 31, 2019] » An evening of space prog and singer/songwriter adventcha! Space Rats hit the stage at 830 to soundtrack a projection of the classic Beastmaster. Escape Goats and Ladybug Infestation work their usual magic!
-5/18/2019 7:30:27 PM
Mrk Eyz @adx [May 19, 2019] » New location. All ages!
-5/16/2019 2:49:19 PM
FCUK YEAHH @starday tavern [Jul 19, 2019] » WOO!!!
-5/12/2019 5:46:31 PM
jonathan @high water mark [May 10, 2019] » OK
-5/10/2019 4:43:59 PM
Da Punx I think you should go see Sad Horse. Jenny Don't and the Spurs sucks (rehash tired fucking bullshit/nothingoriginal.) 503 punx reprezent!
-5/3/2019 3:37:28 AM
bastardsalt KENTON CLUB - TONIGHT. FREE. NONE ep release show. LOUD, FUN, FUCK YEAH!
-5/2/2019 3:50:52 PM
Jenny @adx [May 19, 2019] » Dayyyyyyyyuuum
-5/1/2019 4:17:04 PM
Mark Saturday, May 11th, at Gil's Speakeasy, black metal show with STAVVES from Corona, CA and PDX locals, Trow & At the Heart of the World!
-5/1/2019 2:25:16 PM
nikxt Can you add a good punk show for Fruday (4/26). Hardcore, post-punk or '77. Thanks!!
-4/24/2019 11:32:08 AM
nikxt BoardIsLife > Terminal-Boredom forum
-4/19/2019 2:40:05 AM
nikxt @ Mike! I don't use Facebook. Not punk. Ain't used social media since Myspace in 2004.
-4/19/2019 2:34:03 AM
Mike @house show ~ ask a flower [Apr 19, 2019] » Face book message yhe bands for address.
-4/16/2019 11:57:18 AM
Mike @slims [Apr 20, 2019] » Heres the link to the event..... ¤"ref"%3A"2"%2C"ref_dashboard_filter"%3A"calendar"%2C"action_history"%3A"[%7B%5C"surface%5C"%3A%5C"dashboard%5C"%2C%5C"mechanism%5C"%3A%5C"main_list%5C"%2C%5C"extra_data%5C"%3A[]%7D]"%7D&ref=bookmarks
-4/16/2019 11:51:22 AM
nikxt @tanker, the [Apr 12, 2019] » Nice!
-4/12/2019 7:45:53 PM
bastardsalt @tanker, the [Apr 12, 2019] » Unfortunately (and bummed), Trash pulled out of the show at Tanker, but Bad Channels have barreled onto their slot. ¤ ¤ The show must go on!
-4/11/2019 3:47:12 PM
Im so dumb The Briefs should come to PDX. They suck now. Still want them to cum tho.
-4/3/2019 12:46:59 PM
show-bot! @moda center (rose garden) [Apr 12, 2019] » fuckoff with this nonsense
-4/3/2019 12:44:01 PM
Nicholas @fixin' to, the [Mar 23, 2019] » Get tix ahead of time! Link in FB event page link! Will sell out! Don't blow it! This show is going to blow the roof off!
-3/18/2019 8:23:17 PM
BIG BUSINESS + GAYTHEIST + NASALROD @mississippi studios [Apr 16, 2019] » Ummmm...this is gonna RULE! Tuesday, April 16th at Mississippi Studios! Don't sleep on tix!!💯💯💯
-3/9/2019 4:28:36 PM
tammy @killingsworth dynasty [Feb 28, 2019] » poster says killingsworth dynasty. listed at white owl.
-2/28/2019 10:49:39 AM
dougcapello @FAQ/WTF?! : How to Get Your Band Listed and Post a New Bio » Hey, we don't have access to removing a harmful/explicit profile that ended up on this page. Does anyone know how we can do this? Haven't had luck hearing back from webmaster yet.
-2/25/2019 11:11:41 PM
pc-pdx this is the new server. ok. cool.
-2/22/2019 2:12:02 PM

If you would like to comment on this page, please leave a comment in the box in the main content area and it will appear in the shoutbox complete with linkage.